Sibling Age Gaps: My Honest Take on 4 Years vs. 20 Months
A mom of three shares her honest take on a 4-year vs. 20-month sibling age gap—the sweet moments, hard parts, and timing we don’t always get to choose.
MOM LIFE
11/5/20264 min read
If you’re pregnant with your second and wondering what the age gap will actually feel like, this one’s for you.
I have three kids: a 7-year-old, a 3-year-old, and a 1-year-old. That means I’ve experienced a bigger gap— four years—and a smaller one—20 months. Two very different seasons of motherhood, and yes, I have opinions.
Grab your coffee. Hot, if you’re lucky.
The Sibling Age Gaps in Our Family
Here’s how the spacing worked out in our house:
Oldest to middle: 4 years apart
Middle to youngest: 20 months apart
Before I get into the differences, there’s a piece of our story I want to acknowledge: I had a miscarriage between my oldest and my middle child. That loss is part of why we have a bigger age gap.
I’m not sharing the whole story here, but it matters to this conversation. When we talk about the “best” time to have another baby, we don’t always leave room for the fact that timing isn’t entirely ours to choose.
So this isn’t a guide to planning the perfect gap. It’s an honest look at what two different gaps have felt like in our family.
The 4-Year Gap: The Helper Era
Here’s the honest truth: there is a lot I love about the bigger gap.
By the time my son arrived, my oldest was potty trained and in preschool. When she was at school, I got real, uninterrupted one-on-one time with my newborn. No double diaper changes. No juggling two babies’ schedules. I had more room to soak in those newborn days.
I was still starting over with a baby, but I wasn’t doing it with another baby on my hip.
And then there’s the big-sister factor.
Watching my oldest step into that role has been so sweet. She grabs a diaper, entertains her brother or sister, and checks on them because she wants to be involved.
Is it terrible to admit how much I appreciate someone fetching a diaper when I’ve finally sat down? Because I really do.
But being their sister is her role—not being another parent. I’m careful not to make helping her responsibility. The moments when she chooses to join in have simply been a lovely bonus.
The trade-off is that my oldest and the younger two are in different stages. They aren’t always interested in the same things, and my oldest is experiencing school milestones that the little ones aren’t close to yet.
That doesn’t take away from their relationship. It just means their time together looks different.
The 20-Month Gap: The Trenches
Let’s not sugarcoat it: two under two was tough.
At the beginning, we had:
Two kids in diapers
Two kids who weren’t consistently sleeping through the night
A baby who needed me and a toddler who still needed so much of me, too
That last part was a big one. My son became a big brother, but he was still so little himself.
The four-year gap gave me more breathing room. The 20-month gap often felt like everyone needed something at exactly the same time.
But here’s the flip side: as the little two have grown, watching them play together has been so much fun.
They chase each other around the house, and their little friendship is becoming one of my favorite things to watch. My son has been sweet with his baby sibling from the start, and I haven’t seen the jealousy I wondered about.
I also look forward to the overlap they’ll have in their school years. My oldest is navigating that stage without a sibling alongside her right now, and she’s doing great. With the younger two, I’m excited to see what sharing more of those everyday experiences will look like.
Which Age Gap Felt Easier to Me?
For me, the bigger gap was easier, especially in the newborn stage.
My oldest could do more for herself. She was out of diapers. And preschool gave me pockets of time to focus on the baby without also meeting a toddler’s needs.
The smaller gap brought more hands-on demands at once. There wasn’t much separation between one child needing baby-level care and the next child arriving.
But easier and better aren’t the same thing.
There are things I treasure about both—and things that have stretched me in completely different ways.
4 Years vs. 20 Months: My Quick Comparison
4-Year Gap
What I loved:
More one-on-one time with the baby while my oldest was at preschool
Only one child in diapers
An older sibling who could do more independently
Sweet moments of my oldest choosing to help
What felt harder:
Different interests and stages
Less overlap in the things they could all enjoy early on
School experiences happening on different timelines
20-Month Gap
What I love:
Watching their play and friendship develop
Seeing my son be so sweet with his younger sibling
Looking forward to more overlap in their school years
What felt harder:
Two children in diapers
Overlapping sleep struggles
Meeting a baby’s needs while still caring for a very young toddler
So many hands-on needs happening at once
We Don’t Always Get to Choose the Timing
I can tell you which gap felt easier for me. But I can’t separate those gaps from the story of how our family grew.
The miscarriage between my oldest and middle child is part of that story. I can love our family as it is and still acknowledge the loss that came before.
That’s why I don’t want this comparison to become another thing for a mom to feel she has to get “right.”
Maybe you’re hoping for a close gap. Maybe you want more time. Maybe the gap you’re expecting isn’t the one you pictured.
I can’t tell you exactly what your version will feel like. I can tell you that mine have each held hard days and moments I wouldn’t trade.
There Isn’t One Gap I’d Call “Best”
The four-year gap gave me more breathing room in the early days. The 20-month gap asked more of me at once, and now I get to watch a sweet little friendship develop.
Neither experience has been all easy or all hard.
If you’re expecting your second and feeling nervous about the spacing, you’re not alone. I’ve loved things about both of our age gaps, and I’ve found parts of both challenging.
You don’t have to know exactly how it’s all going to work before your baby arrives. I certainly didn’t.




STAY CONNECTED
GET IN TOUCH
Questions or ideas?
AngelaMarie@mommakeshome.com
© 2026. All rights reserved
